• Sign Up
    • Login
    • Register
  • Mobile Search
  • News
  • Favoutires
  • Sign Up
    • Login
    • Register
  • Projects
    • Rigs
      • Complete Rigs
      • Tactile
      • Motion
      • Wheel Mounts
      • Monitor Mounts
      • Seat Mounts
      • Pedal Mounts
      • Rig Accessories
    • Wheels
      • Complete Wheels
      • Button Plates
      • Wheel Accessories
    • Gear
      • Pedals
      • Shifters
      • Button Boxes
      • Displays
      • Handbrakes
      • Flight Controls
      • Other Sim Gear
  • Guides
    • Projects
    • Reviews
    • How-tos
    • Assembly Guides
  • Brands
    • Affiliates
    • Stores
    • Sim Rigs
    • Sim Racing
    • Sim Flight
    • Electronic Components
    • Motion
  • User Gallery
    • Steering Wheels
    • Sim Rigs
    • Sim Gear
  • Forum
    • User Profile
    • My Topics
HomeGuidesReviewsBattle of the Exciters - A Tactile Review

Battle of the Exciters - A Tactile Review

An Exciting Review about DIY Shifter Tactile Feedback with SimHub

07 March 2023
Stuyo
Reviews
15906 views

0
Shares
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Copy Link
  • Love

    Battle of the Exciters - A Tactile Review Image 1
  • 1. Battle of the Exciters - A Tactile Review
  • 2. Overview, Pricing, Specifications
  • 3. Closer Look, Test Bench and Sequence
  • 4. Mounting Options, Score System
  • 5. Measurements and Tests
  • 6. Further Impressions and Summary
  • 7. Conclusion
  • - All pages -

Overview

We will review several popular options amongst sim racer as well as some not so common ones. Recently Dayton updated their range of products with new interchangeable mounting system and some of their most popular models now feature it. We will see also what it brings to the table.

All of the exciters come with pre-applied adhesive tape, which is quite solid and will hold them in place without issue. The only one labelled as bass shaker - the Dayton PUCK - needs different mounting solution due to its size and weight. We also tested with the same heavy duty adhesive tape - works quite OK:

images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/exciters_front.jpg

Our exciting bunch

images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/exciters_back.jpg

View from behind

 

This is a good comparison picture giving you relative feel how big each exciter is:

Exciters stacked by height

Exciters stacked by height

 

And here are those two awesome disks of power which we will take as baseline - full size, 50 Watts to rumble your bones:

Dayton Audio BST-1 and Aura Sound AST-2B-4

Dayton Audio BST-1 and Aura Sound AST-2B-4

 

Weight

Weight could seem irrelevant, it is not like you will carry them on your back, but actually has significance here. As exciter coils are attached to the mount surface actually the whole body vibrates. Weighting them is good comparison on how much moving mass they have. Exclusion here are of course the three bass shakers - they do not have any external moving components and everything is enclosed inside the body:

images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/weight001.jpg
images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/weight002.jpg
images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/weight003.jpg
images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/weight004.jpg
images/articles/reviews/exciters/01_overview/weight005.jpg

Pricing and Specifications

All prices are current at the time when the review was published. We will take into account the new Exciter models - they are considerably more expensive but in our opinion the added value of the new mount is worth it. More on that you can read further on in the review.

Device Power Impedance Coil Weight Price
Dayton Audio TT25 PUCK Tactile Transducer Mini Bass Shaker 15W 8 Ohm   283gr 16.95 EUR
Dayton Audio EX32U2-4 Sound Exciter 20W 4 Ohm 32mm 142gr 36.45 EUR
Dayton Audio DAEX58FP Sound Exciter 25W 8 Ohm 32mm 119gr 19.95 EUR
Dayton Audio EX30HESF-4 High Efficiency Steered Flux Sound Exciter 40W 4 Ohm 30mm 157gr 44.95 EUR
Dayton Audio EX32EP2-4 Thruster Sound Exciter 40W 4 Ohm 32mm 128gr 38.45 EUR
Dayton Audio BST-1 High Power Pro Tactile Bass Shaker 50W 4 Ohm   1.75KG 54.95 EUR
AuraSound AST-2B-4 Pro Bass Shaker Tactile Transducer 50W 4 Ohm   1.7KG 99.95 EUR

Now is time to deep dive and go over some of the exciters' features in Closer Look, Test Bench and Sequence:

Previous Page 2 / 7 Next Page
Add comment
JComments

New Projects

  • Magnetic Paddle Shifter V4 - IMG_6198_d7e1647215b0dfe5b4ae952c95b96e5b
    Magnetic Paddle Shifter V4 - IMG_6198_d7e1647215b0dfe5b4ae952c95b96e5b
    Magnetic Paddle Shifter V4
  • Fanatec Podium Kill-Switch - IMG_4866_5ae2c98fc136195b02f6fe17692e5d90
    Fanatec Podium Kill-Switch - IMG_4866_5ae2c98fc136195b02f6fe17692e5d90
    Fanatec Podium Kill-Switch
  • Sim Rig Cable Management for Stepper Drivers - IMG_5079_dba9e50a772ffdfebca281fde2544a24
    Sim Rig Cable Management for Stepper Drivers - IMG_5079_dba9e50a772ffdfebca281fde2544a24
    Sim Rig Cable Management for Stepper Drivers
  • Thanos AMC Vertical Mount - IMG_4978_d29fffc8c4719b546bcd1637ad2fec83
    Thanos AMC Vertical Mount - IMG_4978_d29fffc8c4719b546bcd1637ad2fec83
    Thanos AMC Vertical Mount
  • Power Splitter Junction Box - IMG_4930_814e1d37c9c5ed64eb49eb13aa8b7f90
    Power Splitter Junction Box - IMG_4930_814e1d37c9c5ed64eb49eb13aa8b7f90
    Power Splitter Junction Box

    Affiliates


      Powered by Warp Theme Framework